Dear Great Book Guru,
I was at the Friends of the Library gala “Fun-Raiser” last night- and what fun it was! A group of revelers was discussing a number
of books including “Dog Whistle Politics, ” “White Trash,” “ The New Jim Crow
Politics,” plus another title I can’t remember. I plan on reading all of them so
can you help me with that last one? A
Fervent Fan of the Friends of the Library
Dear Fervent Fan of…
The Friends of the Library is a favorite of mine too and –yes- I have
read the book you are interested in HILLBILLY ELEGY by J.D. Vance. This is a bestselling memoir of a childhood
spent in Ohio and Kentucky, the author’s years as a U.S. Marine, and finally
his success as a Yale Law School
graduate. He writes of his upbringing in a household where violence and
multiple addictions were counterbalanced by fierce family loyalties and an intense love of country. He writes of the many- as he sees them- bad decisions
made by his family, while still maintaining a strong affection for them. The
roles of government, racism, and culture in his family’s misfortunes are
analyzed in detail interspersed with at times terrifying incidents from his
boyhood. In the end, Vance denounces a culture of “helplessness” that he sees as
integral to his family and community’s malaise, while underplaying the role of economics
and punitive government policy. An interesting read but recommended with some reservation...